Tesla Introduces Safety Score Disputes for Tesla Insurance

Tesla announced a significant update for its insurance policyholders regarding the Safety Score system. Currently, a single Forward Collision Warning (FCW) triggered by various factors such as a parked car, shadows, or unusual road shapes can lead to unexpected hikes in monthly premiums. For some time now, Tesla vehicle owners have been requesting a method to contest these false positives, but until now, no process existed. Previously, all data collected by the vehicle was considered definitive, even when inaccuracies arose.

With the latest software update to the Tesla App, version 4.51.7, the automaker appears to be laying the groundwork for a Safety Score Dispute system. Investigations into the app's source code have revealed new strings that suggest this functionality is currently under development, enabling drivers to challenge specific incidents that adversely affect their ratings.

How the Feature Operates

Although this feature remains undocumented and is not yet live on the user interface, the backend development provides a glimpse into how the system will function. Key variables identified within the code include:

• safety_score_dispute_a_trip
• safety_score_reason_for_dispute
• safety_score_supporting_documents
• safety_score_dispute_history
• safety_score_max_disputes_reached

This new terminology in the app indicates that Tesla is likely conducting tests on the feature, which will create a structured process allowing users to choose a specific trip associated with a negative event—like an FCW or Hard Braking incident—and select a reason for disputing it. Users can expect to monitor the progress of their claims during the review phase. Importantly, the presence of the max_disputes_reached string suggests there will be a limit on the number of events that can be contested, which likely aims to prevent misuse of the system for trivial issues.

Why This Timing?

The timing of this announcement is particularly relevant, coinciding with the rollout of the new Dashcam Telemetry features included in the 2025 Holiday Update. Previously, any dispute would hinge solely on the owner's word against the car's sensor data. However, the introduction of Dashcam Telemetry now allows owners to present verified, concrete data to back their claims. For instance, if a vehicle experiences an FCW on an empty road, owners can now upload the Dashcam footage accompanied by telemetry data as supporting evidence.

The Significance of This Development

This function is crucial, particularly in regions where Tesla Insurance is active, excluding California, as the Safety Score plays a direct role in determining insurance pricing. A false positive is not just a nuisance; it can lead to substantial financial repercussions for vehicle owners. Providing a clear avenue for contesting these inaccuracies addresses one of the biggest challenges currently faced by users of Tesla Insurance. While the insurance service is available in a limited number of states, it is expected that Tesla will broaden its reach to additional areas in the future.

Stay updated by subscribing to our newsletter for the latest news on Tesla, including upcoming features and software updates.